Quote from: mrf on March 07, 2026, 18:11:201 year warranty in EU is impossible.
TLDR: In the EU, every new product has a mandatory 2-year legal guarantee from the seller. Apple's 1-year warranty is an additional voluntary commercial guarantee and usually adds little to no practical value. This should be made clear in the article.
⸻
There is a difference between the
legal guarantee (in German: Gewährleistung) and a
commercial guarantee, which Apple calls a
warranty (in German: Garantie).
Under EU law, every newly purchased product comes with a
2-year legal guarantee. This means the seller is responsible if the product does not conform to the contract (for example, if it stops working because of a manufacturing defect). In such cases, you are entitled to a repair, a replacement, a price reduction, or a refund.
In addition, manufacturers or sellers may offer
commercial guarantees. These are voluntary and can be free or paid. Apple provides both: the
free 1-year limited warranty and the paid AppleCare+ extension.
In EU countries, the free 1-year commercial guarantee adds little to no practical value compared to the mandatory 2-year legal guarantee. Therefore, the statement "comes with only a 1-year warranty" is technically correct but can be confusing, since consumers in the EU still benefit from the 2-year legal guarantee.
However, the free 1-year commercial guarantee is the same worldwide, so it may provide additional value in countries where consumer protection laws offer shorter or weaker legal guarantees.
I agree with you insofar as the author should make this clearer and write something like:
"In addition to the legal 2-year guarantee in the EU, Apple offers a free 1-year commercial guarantee, which adds little to no practical value, and the paid commercial guarantee AppleCare+, which also covers accidental damage."However, to make a comment like this on every tested product, one would need to read every commercial guarantee and compare it to the legal 2-year guarantee. That would probably require a whole additional legal team to do properly.