NotebookCHECK - Notebook Forum

English => News => Topic started by: Redaktion on August 09, 2023, 11:53:48

Title: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Redaktion on August 09, 2023, 11:53:48
First gigacast Cybertruck body sections have little to show for Elon Musk's exoskeleton concept revealed when announcing its first electric pickup. 'People familiar with the matter' now tell why.

https://www.notebookcheck.net/Cybertruck-exoskeleton-concept-is-no-longer-viable-for-Tesla.739926.0.html
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: ricegf on August 10, 2023, 06:11:04
Part of me is disappointed, because it sounded very cool. But part of me is relieved, because I didn't see how a crunched exoskeleton could be repaired without a LOT of work.

I'll miss the seating for 6 burly construction workers, though.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Mike Smith on August 10, 2023, 06:40:50
You are way off base. 90% of what you are saying and spreading is wrong. You clearly have never been in this factory and know nothing about production methods. Do you realize the equipment that makes this truck had to be invented. It did not exist. The engineering challenges alone that had to be overcome are staggering. To hear you critique it with almost zero knowledge is sad. Its just click bait. I work in GFTX and know much about CT. Lets leave it there. Please report on how to make a pencil vs manufacturing of a automobile. Seriously.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Mike Smith on August 10, 2023, 06:45:02
Quote from: ricegf on August 10, 2023, 06:11:04Part of me is disappointed, because it sounded very cool. But part of me is relieved, because I didn't see how a crunched exoskeleton could be repaired without a LOT of work.

I'll miss the seating for 6 burly construction workers, though.



THINK ABOUT IT. IF IT IS A EXOSKELETON WOILD YOU NOT BE ABLE TO UNBOLT IT AND REBOLT ANOTHER ONE IN ITS PLACE? DONT BE DISAPPOINTED. IT IS A TRULY WORK OF ART THAT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE BEFORE.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Waste mytime on August 10, 2023, 07:45:46
The articles contains lots of may be this and may be that and nothing of essence.

Is this the standard of journalist nowadays.

Do some proper research and verify what you spew out pls.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Petar on August 10, 2023, 08:26:01
Unfortunately Mr Musk is nog an automotive engineer or designer and was
talking utter nonsense about the supposedly revolutionary exoskeloton. Its turned out that it is now just like a Honda Ridgeline, which was heavily criticized for not being a "real" truck as it didnt have a separate frame.Well it does have some castings added so thats something. I hope that the Tesla fanboys can live with that.
Anyone that has worked in the automotive industry knew that the proposal flouted by Mr Musk wasnt feasible as unfortunately there are factors like crash zones and manufacturing etc to concider.The Cybertruck is a flashy toy for rich yuppies to go get a latte from Starbuck in or go pick up some flowers and potting soil from Home Depot.Its rather striking but no worktruck.

Talking about producing an exoskeleton is easier than building one.Much like talking about hyperloop trains that run at 270mph that then turn into taxis running at 30mph in a tunnel driven by an Uber driver.

Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Kali on August 10, 2023, 08:32:33
What your spreading is false information and it shows to anyone that knows anything about how vehicle design works and manufacturing that you know by the sounds of it literally nothing please research what the castings are and what part of the vehicle they are before you post something like this
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Amjmelb on August 10, 2023, 10:26:11
So it's a unibody pickup truck?

LOL, how "groundbreaking"
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Nottoday on August 10, 2023, 16:08:41
What a surprise, the Elon dickriders screeching in the comments about supposed inaccuracies but of course they can't give an example, because their opinion comes entirely from emotion.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Pete Namlook on August 10, 2023, 17:01:14
Why is no one else talking about the fact that the OP keeps saying it is made of steel when it is really stainless steel?

I hate Tesla and even I know that.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Jettrod on August 10, 2023, 17:17:48
How different could an exoskeleton actually be from a unibody? Neither have a frame, instead relying on the body to keep things square and in alignment.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Chad on August 10, 2023, 17:32:29
Will believe this when Musk says so, otherwise just more nobodies online throwing shade.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: MishterKirby on August 10, 2023, 17:36:42
Quote from: Mike Smith on August 10, 2023, 06:45:02THINK ABOUT IT. IF IT IS A EXOSKELETON WOILD YOU NOT BE ABLE TO UNBOLT IT AND REBOLT ANOTHER ONE IN ITS PLACE? DONT BE DISAPPOINTED. IT IS A TRULY WORK OF ART THAT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE BEFORE.

Wouldn't that basically be a whole rebuild, though?

Also, DO WE SERIOUSLY HAVE TO YELL SO MUCH?

Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Truckeng on August 10, 2023, 18:00:28
It was never going to pass US crash tests. It was never going to be delivered at the price point promised.

NHTSA saved Musk from the exoskeleton concept. Inflation saved him from the price point.

Good thing for him that he didn't enter into some sort of binding agreement that forced him to deliver, like he did with Twitter.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Burglekutt on August 10, 2023, 19:21:03
Elmo is the king of simps and chads. He's a felcher through and through. f*** him!
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: stan on August 10, 2023, 22:04:41
I see..... vapourware.... dead vapourware...
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Mike Hawk on August 10, 2023, 22:11:35
>You clearly have never been in this factory and know nothing about production methods.

You ever been in that factory?
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Rickyroo on August 10, 2023, 22:31:56
More clickbait. Nonsense. It's not an exoskeleton it's a steel exterior. The author is still wondering why Tesla is number 1 selling car in the USA . How can this be?
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Davinda on August 11, 2023, 01:07:41
Quote from: Burglekutt on August 10, 2023, 19:21:03Elmo is the king of simps and chads. He's a felcher through and through. f*** him!

Elon is a Chad LMAO!
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Thomas gieseler on August 11, 2023, 02:46:36
Would like to see crash tests done front sides and rear that would tell the whole story !!!!!
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Eron Musk on August 11, 2023, 03:09:00
If the author took 5 minutes to look at the Tesla exoskeleton patent that was submitted back in 2019, they would see that the exoskeleton design in the patent is EXACTLY what was observed in the factory spy shots.  The lies and BS from the fake wall street journal people "in the know" comes from a video where Munro & Associates speculated that the exoskeleton design might be based on stainless steel sheets metal that would be folded up like origami using metal brakes and laser scoring.  When Munro later saw the spy images they immediately dismissed it as "not an exoskeleton" when it didn't look like their fantasized interpretation of what an exoskeleton design might look like.  They too, never bothered to actually look at the publicly available patent.  Wholly unsurprising as to what you talentless, lazy bloggers consider journalism.  Whatever it takes to push a narrative and get clicks from simpletons, amiright?
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Eron Rust on August 11, 2023, 03:47:44
Tesla will never sell this monstrosity of a truck.
Too expensive and butt ugly!
Let's be honest,  Americans will continue to buy big gas-burning hulks.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: RobbyRobAZ on August 11, 2023, 03:58:21
What a poor article! Like the gigacast is bad thing?
The gigacast is awesome. It's one of a kind and the largest ever.
If they had to make a few compromises to add crumple zones that fine.
For the most part the vehicle is one or two solid molds.
So sick of the same looking pickup for 80 years.
We should be way more advanced in our vehicles but innovation slowed so much in the last 20 years it's silly.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Pj on August 11, 2023, 04:56:34
You gotta love the haters in this. It cracks me up lol!
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Davea0511 on August 11, 2023, 16:44:44
Why does the mere mention of Musk bring out all the crazies? On both side of the fence. He's just a brand name with a team that hires great talent, and knows how to get them to do amazing stuff. Stop taking his successes and failures so personally.
Anywho, I'm just glad to know now that if I get in a small fender bender that I won't have  to replace the entire body.
Title: Re: Cybertruck exoskeleton concept is no longer viable for Tesla
Post by: Zuck on August 12, 2023, 06:46:39
I call him Elon Mucks cuz he mucks up everything he does