Post reply

Message icon:


shortcuts: hit alt+s to submit/post or alt+p to preview

Topic Summary

Posted by: jeremy
« on: May 26, 2017, 12:02:42 »

With ubuntu, wqhd is not too big resolution?
Posted by: dthrp
« on: May 12, 2017, 15:35:51 »

As I always ended up with 3/4 of NBC's measured battery life, the runtimes are pretty disappointing. See here's what I don't understand.

Lenovo's own consumer flagship Yoga 910 packs a 4-cell 78 Whr battery in a chassis that practically weighs the same as the T470s. LG's Gram 13" has a smaller display, weighs only 0.94 kg, and yet still packs a 60 Whr battery, all the while, keeping a non-soldered ram slot. Build quality is no longer an excuse for the T470s, especially since both the Yoga and the Gram have both dramatically improved their build quality and battery capacity, while simultaneously not gaining additional weight.

There's more. IME, the T460s' keyboard was significantly mushier and shallower than what I expect from a business laptop. It's more comparable to MSI's Steelseries keyboard, not even the giant gaming rigs but the lightweight ones, which is satisfactory, but still very sub-par from a "business" standard. Keycap texture of backlit keyboard was one of the worst I've used, and I've tested laptops for years. Finger oil and sweat smudge all over and it's virtually impossible to type with nails, so can't recommend to any female clients. Then they went on to use the same cheap keyboard on their most expensive P series, laptops for the pros that cost over three grand, and completely ruined the experience. Frankly, I've no idea why so many reviewers praise the workstation keyboard at all, when it's not even marginally better than many business think&light. Maybe it was due to every internet forum user saying it's a magical experience, but it all turned out to be a huge bluff to me. On the other hand, T460 and T560 were surprisingly good, but travel and tactility varied heavily on keyboard vendors. Only recommendable keyboards with decent quality and QC were the X1C and Thinkpad 13, which unfortunately weren't what my clients needed. In the end, we went with the T460 and swapped out more than half of the units' keyboards with a better vendor's.

Then there's the screen and audio, albeit more personal, but are still distasteful. And many more issues, which I won't go into here.

I do acknowledge, that they don't want to make a single perfect laptop like Apple, Dell XPS, or Gigabyte Aorus. I know that since the beginning, it's been their active strategy to split the laptops into different lines and models, with crippling compromises, to target a larger audience and minimize the costs.
However, what I don't get, is why they won't offer upgrades for select users who're willing to pay the premium price, when they are perfectly capable of providing such. I'll gladly pay for those upgrades, or even better, for a single perfect laptop, with all the best, cherry-picked features from your entire series, if you create such a thing.

Point is, Lenovo has cut too much costs in areas where they absolutely shouldn't have, and charges unreasonably more for less. While Dell has actually done some great work with both their consumer and business lines. This year, more than half of the Thinkpad X,T,P series are difficult to recommend to anybody, and the only reason I do is because they regularly hold massive discounts, and because of relatively cheaper used prices. And as someone with some respect for the brand, that's seriously disappointing to say the least.
Posted by: JanM
« on: April 26, 2017, 11:06:44 »

Does is work with Ubuntu 16:04 LTS (on another distro) out of the box?

Regards, Jan

To answer my own question. I bought the T470s ((20HF004QMH). I works like charm with Ubuntu 16:04.2 LTS, without any need for modifications.
Posted by: CnZhx
« on: April 14, 2017, 10:26:45 »

Could you please confirm the type of memory is 2400MHz instead of 2133MHz? I could not find the option of 2400MHz from Lenovo website.
Posted by: JanM
« on: April 10, 2017, 16:41:15 »

Does is work with Ubuntu 16:04 LTS (on another distro) out of the box?

Regards, Jan
Posted by: Maciek
« on: March 24, 2017, 11:48:49 »

Anybody knows what's the gamut of FullHD version ?
Posted by: questions
« on: March 22, 2017, 21:21:39 »

I am confused regarding the findings of the CPU being temperature throttled.

In the review text it is stated

"Another problem is the performance on battery power, because the CPU cannot even maintain its base frequency. We can see between ~2.2-2.4 GHz in Cinebench R15 Multi, despite the High Performance power plan. The result is a score of just 203 points, a 45% performance drop! The adjustment of the BIOS settings did not help, either."

However, in the performance charts the T470s comes out on top in all tests and the Cinebench R15 Multi score in the chart is 386 and not 203!?!

What gives?
Posted by: Erravi
« on: March 20, 2017, 23:26:56 »

It appears that author of the review received a t470s from Lenovo with a good quality AUO screen... History predicts that most of the "ordinary" customers will very likely receive laptops with lower quality screens (LG?) from now on :)
Posted by: Name
« on: March 14, 2017, 19:07:05 »

Another TP shit. This time 2099E?  ;D ;D ;D
Posted by: Anonymous
« on: March 12, 2017, 13:33:42 »

"We did not really understand the solution with two integrated batteries "  Lenovo might be recycling old batteries... :)
Sure, they are most certainly interested is reusing as much parts as they can with the previous models (so it's easier to keep the FRUs and cheaper for the production line).

However, I think the root cause may come down to the design of the unit, which is actually a T460s chassis that in turn was a shrunk T450s.
The T450s had the much useful power-bridge (that allows to replace the battery without powering down the machine). When the shrunk for the T460s was made, they could no longer keep the removable back battery, so they were faced with an hard choice: either redesign the whole thing from scratch, so that weight distribution and hinges actually work properly *or* just hide the (previously) external battery inside the case and get away with tweaks to an existing design.

I think we all know what the choice was...
Posted by: VCC
« on: March 10, 2017, 05:28:10 »

Is it possible to undervolt the processor on this machine? May help with the throttling.
Posted by: brok magellan
« on: March 09, 2017, 11:59:36 »

"We did not really understand the solution with two integrated batteries "  Lenovo might be recycling old batteries... :)

You could try increasing thermal limits for yourself in uefi / bios, but i think it difficult task, you must have IFR uefi values descriptor and look for variables like trip point/temperature. and then boot into grub with uefi and issue commands setup_var [num] [value]

The decreased frequency on battery could be explained with TDP level value OR Disable turbo flag. Use throttlestop to set/read.
Posted by: mcmxcii
« on: March 09, 2017, 01:39:42 »

Hi, we expect the test model of the new X1 Carbon by the end of the week.

Please also include the speed of the microSD card reader,
which was not mentioned in previous X1 Carbon reviews.
Posted by: Luca Repetti
« on: March 08, 2017, 17:44:57 »

Hello guys, thanks for your work; when are you going to review the new ThinkPad 13? Thanks a lot!
Posted by: Andreas Osthoff
« on: March 08, 2017, 11:09:31 »

Hi, we expect the test model of the new X1 Carbon by the end of the week.

» Impressum     Sprachen: Deutsch | English | Español | Français | Italiano | Nederlands | Polski | Português | Русский | Türkçe | Svenska
Diese Webseite nutzt Cookies. OK