NotebookCHECK - Notebook Forum

English => Reviews => Topic started by: Redaktion on June 24, 2020, 19:30:48

Title: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Redaktion on June 24, 2020, 19:30:48
It's not the quietest or best-looking gaming laptop out there, but $860 USD for GeForce RTX 2060-level graphics and Core i7-like performance is hard to argue with. The value of the all-AMD G5 15 Special Edition is impressive.

https://www.notebookcheck.net/Going-all-in-on-AMD-Dell-G5-15-Special-Edition-Radeon-RX-5600M-Laptop-Review.477090.0.html
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Justin A. on June 24, 2020, 20:52:37
Good review, but I really don't understand how the ratings work. How is it that such a hot-running laptop gets 84% score?
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Rikii on June 25, 2020, 00:19:15
I don't understand the rating either.
"There are notable disadvantages to keep in mind with temperature and fan noise being the most striking. "
Then they rate the noise level 99% good.
Also it has well above average web-camera/microphone combo and it get's 44%
i mean.... ????
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Worldliner on June 25, 2020, 04:37:08
This is the first time ever I saw a GPU running at 93 degrees. Nvidia GPUs hit therm-cap well lower than that. Can imagine how terrible g5 Nvidia edition will perform.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Padmakara on June 25, 2020, 08:21:27
Nice review, Keep up the good work
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: seonho on June 25, 2020, 10:52:22
This is unique laptop available with 4600H and 5600M so my disappointment with screen is immeasurable.
If Intel version of G15 doesn't come with devastating agressive 200 PWM then Dell will have a big PR problem.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: vekspec on June 25, 2020, 13:57:51
My competing Tuf A15 runs cooler than this. 1660ti is in the 70s and 4800H doesn't go above 90, avgs around 80. Don't think any of my Nvidia gpus in my laptops have gone above 80 (1660ti, 2060 or 2070 all in the 70s). Another reason not to go AMD GPU :p

Even the surface temps are cooler. WASD are cool, not like this one's ~44deg! Disappointing Dell and to think I almost went for it.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: havefun on June 25, 2020, 16:03:30
Again terrible review, turn on Adrenaline features like Radeon boost.....
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: DeepskyScorpion on June 25, 2020, 21:20:58
I see people complaining about the high temps and citing how Nvidia doesn't do that. With Nvidia also heading into smaller nodes, I am looking forward to see that change.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: SCARed on June 25, 2020, 23:36:32
great review. what I still don't get: why Dell is not using adaptive synch? this is just a big waste of potential!

all in a sudden the Asus A15 beccame much more appealing, as this one also add USB.C (gen. 2).

such a pitty, as I had high hope for this "all-AMD"-laptop.  :-[
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Disciple7 on June 28, 2020, 10:16:49
Why are you lying about the adaptive sync. I have the same laptop and it came with adaptive sync right out of the box, the driver on amd's website patches it if you dont have it out of the box. Please change that.  Or worse case you use CRU. Your gaming perf sketchy aswell mine runs better on most of your benchmarks.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: SCARed on June 28, 2020, 20:20:25
Thx pal, that info about adaptive Synch is at least good news.

but the high temps and noise are still a big minus.  :-\
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Jordan on July 21, 2020, 05:54:28
From what I've read elsewwhere, not only does the USB-C port no longer support Thunderbolt 3, it no longer supports data at all. It can only carry a Displayport signal. Which is bizarre, as there is already a mini-dp on this laptop.

Can you check to verify if what I've read elsewhere is true?
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Himank on October 12, 2020, 09:37:53
I've heard that you need to manually max out the fans on this laptop. This is based on Hardware Cannucks' testing.
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: vekspec on October 18, 2020, 02:35:01
Seeing HP Omen being best 4800H gaming laptop. I still don't know why this is #1 budget. It's like one of the worst. Feeling these ratings are becoming more subjective each month.  ::)
Title: Re: Going all in on AMD: Dell G5 15 Special Edition Radeon RX 5600M Laptop Review
Post by: Tyler on June 20, 2021, 06:03:28
Quote from: Jordan on July 21, 2020, 05:54:28
From what I've read elsewwhere, not only does the USB-C port no longer support Thunderbolt 3, it no longer supports data at all. It can only carry a Displayport signal. Which is bizarre, as there is already a mini-dp on this laptop.

Can you check to verify if what I've read elsewhere is true?
Using a USB-C hub on it right now, and it works fine...
Not sure where you got this

Also, my unit runs toasty, with a max recorded at 112°C via Core Temp.